We may earn commission from the links in this post
A broiler pan is often a specially designed set of 2 pans. One sits on top of the other. The bottom pan can be deep or shallow, depending on your purpose. This can, in many cases, be used for alternative cooking methods, such as baking or roasting.
So broiler pans are essentially 2-in-1 kitchen products. But keep in mind that there are also 3 or more-piece models. Nonetheless, its tray generally has holes or slots designed to drain fat away from meat. These are often normal holes or funnels.
These slots typically go across the whole width of the tray in 2 columns. It also helps to circulate hot air. This is to ensure that the food is cooked evenly. You can then enjoy a lean and healthy piece of meat that still has moisture, flavor, and a nice crispy texture.
Broiler Pan Review Center 2019
|#1 - Granite Ware Broiler Pan||99%|
|#2 - Norpro 273 Broiler Pan||97%|
|#3 - Whirlpool 4396923 Broiler Pan||95%|
|#4 - Range Kleen BP106X Broiler Pan||92%|
|#5 - Sur La Table 246598-1 Broiler Pan||90%|
|#6 - Wilton Non-stick Broiler Pan Set||89%|
|#7 - Frigidaire 5304442087 Broiler Pan||87%|
|#8 - General Electric WB48X10056 Broiler Pan||86%|
|#9 - Nordic Ware 42210 Broiler Pan||83%|
|#10 - TeamFar Ovenware Broiler Pan||81%|
Want to learn more?
We chose 10 of the best broiler pans in the market today to help you out. We provided all the details below and rounded this list with the reasons why we like them. Now read on to choose the ideal broiler pan for your kitchen.
It’s made out of carbon steel. This product is manufactured by fusing porcelain to steel at 2000°F.
The carbon steel core of the Granite Ware broiler pan provides strength. This also provides a better, more even cook for your food. The dark broiler color helps to absorb the oven’s energy and produces even cooking results.
The surface of the broiler is made from porcelain enamel. It is inert, non-porous and makes for a naturally non-stick surface. This will reduce the need for scrubbing the broiler clean.
The only negative is that the pan’s likely to chip if you drop it. That’s because its porcelain coating has a glass-type surface. But don’t worry. A chipped surface won’t usually make a difference to the effectiveness of the pan.
You can put this broiler pan in the dishwasher. No more dreading the dishes after a lovely meal. Meanwhile, this broiler is PFOA and PTEE free. So this means it’s free from any harmful chemical.
What You Get When You Buy the Granite Ware broiler Pan
Granite Ware broiler pans are made in the US. The pack is a 3-piece set. It comes with a baking tray, a broiler tray, and a grill rack. You can do more than broil foods.
The broiler tray has small round even holes. These allow the juice to drain straight into the pan. It’s the ideal size to broil meat, fish, vegetables or even a whole meal.
Granite Ware designed this product so you can put this broiler pan directly onto the barbecue if you want to try an alternative. Also, Granite Ware Bake Broil comes with an affordable price tag. This is a reasonable investment for a 3-piece set coming from a trusted brand name.
Other Features We Like From Granite Ware broiler Pans
The words ‘easy to clean’ are something that we tend to doubt. In this case, it is true. The baking tray and the broiler tray of Granite Ware broiler pans are very easy to clean with almost no effort.
Cleaning it in the dishwasher makes it look brand new. Its baking tray isn’t made of the same non-stick material. This means you’ll need to give it a bit of a scrub.
A Granite Ware broiler pan is a useful addition to your kitchen. It doesn’t take up much space. You have three options in one set, so you don’t need to worry about buying extras. If you’re a keen baker, then the grill rack can double up as a cooling rack.
We love how this broiler pan cooks a variety of meat products. It keeps them tender and juicy. Pork chops and chicken wings are moist on the inside and with a crispy coating.
The dimensions of the Norpro 273 broiler pan are 12 inches long, 9 inches wide and 1.5 inches deep. It weighs just 1.43 lbs. Its tray isn’t as deep as some of the others in this roundup, but it’s deep enough to collect juices from cooking.
It’s made from stainless steel. Lots of buyers say this makes it last a long time. You’ll also notice the durability of its tray because of this material.
The Norpro 273 broiler pan is a 2-piece set. Its broiler tray has a perforated top. This might look like something from a science-fiction film, but this shape helps to collect the juice and funnel it to the baking tray.
It’s perforated top also makes it almost impossible for meat to stick on the pan. Using this product is also a healthy way to cook, especially since all the fat from your food can be drained away.
You might be tempted to put this broiler pan in the dishwasher. This isn’t recommended. This won’t damage the tray, but it might affect its durability over some time.
The best way to clean this broiler pan is with a stainless steel scrub. Also, both parts of this 2-piece set are made in Taiwan.
What You Get When You Buy the Norpro 273 broiler Pan
The Norpro 273 broiler pan is a lovely little set if you want to cook thin steaks, fish, and seafood. It works better on boneless chicken. It will cook vegetables and ribs and even toast your bread. The rim is quite wide, so the actual cooking space is reduced. It can still cook enough for a meal for two people.
These broiler pans come at a reasonable price. It costs a little less than the others on this list. It doesn’t have a grill rack, though. But you can use its broil rack in the same way you would a grill rack.
Other Features We Like From Norpro 273 Broiler Pans
Non-stick pans have a bad reputation for being difficult to clean. It isn’t the case here. If you spray the pan with a little cooking oil first, then this makes it easy to clean. And even if you just soak it for 10 minutes, it will clean easily. Keep in mind that its perforated top will need soaking before cleaning.
Its size is perfect for putting it inside the main oven and even some toasting ovens. You can save some time in the kitchen this way. You could even take it with you at the office to make yourself a healthy snack.
The Norpro 273 broiler pan is a much better option than a glass dish to broil food. It can handle higher temperatures without causing any damage to the broil pan. Broiling at higher temperatures leaves a better, browner finish on meats.
The Whirlpool 4396923 broiler pan is compatible with most other oven brands. It’s 16.5 inches long, 12.5 inches wide and 1.8 inches deep. It is a little heavy at 3lbs. This product has a durable porcelain finish and is made to withstand high temperatures.
This product is extremely easy to wash manually. Its porcelain material ensures this. You’re likely to be able just to wipe it clean, depending of course on the food you cook. This product is also dishwasher-safe.
What You Get When You Buy the Whirlpool 4396923 Broiler Pan
The Whirlpool 4396923 broiler pan is a 2-piece set. You’ll get the baking tray and then broil pan. It has a slotted broil pan with wide slots so that fat and juice can drain off. Its slots also have a raised edge to prevent meat and vegetables from sitting too close to the tray.
The design of its boiler tray prevents splatter and smoke when you’re cooking. It reduces the chance of burning and food from having a smoky taste (not the same as a smoked taste!).
This pan is suitable for baking and roasting. In broiler mode, you can cook a wide range of meats and vegetables, full of flavor and crispiness. It also cooks sausages and bacon beautifully.
This broiler pan is a little bit more expensive than the others in this roundup. But you’re guaranteed quality products from Whirlpool.
Other Features We Like From Whirlpool 4396923 Broiler Pans
It’s impressive how the Whirlpool 4396923 broiler pan can fit into practically any standard-sized oven. Also, its heaviness makes it feel quite sturdy. This is mainly due to the durable materials that are used for manufacturing this product.
The best thing about the Whirlpool broiler pan is its design. If you choose to cook with heat from the bottom of the oven, then this would neither burn the food nor warp the pan.
For fatty foods that tend to pop like sausages, this broiler pan stops the fat from covering your entire oven. So this means that not only is the pan easier to clean, but you won’t also have to clean your oven as often.
The Range Kleen BP106X is a compact broiler set. It might not slide into ovens, but it will sit on a tray or a rack. At 12.75 inches long, 8.5 inches wide and 1.33 inches deep, this broiler pan is perfect for ovens, outdoor grills, and camping. It weighs just 1 lb.
This is a heavy-duty set made from Porcelain. It can withstand temperatures of up to 1025°F, making this pan excellent for broiling.
The porcelain material is easy to clean. You can hand wash it or leave it for the dishwasher. Another great advantage with its smaller size is that it won’t take up too much space in the dishwasher.
Its drain slots are wide and relatively deep. This helps to keep fat away from anything you’re cooking. You will have no trouble creating lovely recipes with fish, meat, and vegetables.
What You Get When You Buy the Range Kleen BP106X Broiler Pan
Range Kleen might not be as well-known as the other brands in this list. But they produce top quality broiler pans in the USA.
This product is excellent value for your money at a reasonable price that’s among the most inexpensive ones in this roundup. There’s also an option to buy a pack of 2 at a bargain price. This lets you keep one for the kitchen and another in the car.
Other Features We Like From Range Kleen BP106X Broiler Pans
This product is a nice example of good things coming in small packages. It’s large enough to prepare meat or fish for at least two people. And you’re more likely to use this product because it isn’t so bulky. It isn’t the same as getting out a standard broiler pan and then having to clean it.
The Range Kleen BP106X is quite easy to clean and comes out of the dishwasher looking perfect. The good thing is that you can scrub the pan without scratching its enamel finish in case you accidentally over-cook food (hey, this happens to the best of us!).
Cooking burgers and steaks through this pan is a wonderful experience. Meat is kept moist and full of flavor without any fat. None of the food gets stuck on the pan. Many buyers recommend getting the pack of two because you might want to use these over any other baking tray and broiler pan.
Its bottom tray is deep so it can also be used for baking and roasting. You can use this product to make cakes, pies, or pasta dishes. On the other hand, its top broiling pan acts more like a lid rather than a tray. It has a ¾-inch lip around the edge. So any juice that doesn’t drain away won’t spill over its in.
Its drain slots are deep and wide, allowing fat and juice to drain quickly. This is helpful when you need to turn food over its other side without getting splashed with hot liquids.
It is made from stainless steel. This makes it sturdy yet lightweight. This material is of high quality and made in China. The Sur La Table pan can withstand high temperatures without any damage to the base of the pan.
What You Get When You Buy the Sur La Table 246598-1 Broiler Pan
The Sur La Table 246598-1 broiler pan is a 2-piece set that can cook vegetables to perfection, just like meat and fish. If you add oils for flavor, then the excess will drain away without too much effort on your part.
You can soak this broiler pan in bubbly water and wipe away any dirt, or put it in the dishwasher. Not only is the Sur La Table 246598-1 broiler easy to clean, but it’s also very stylish compared to others in this roundup.
This product has a price tag that’s a little bit higher than the others in this list. But this broiler pan can be used for a wider variety of food and is also made out of durable, lightweight materials.
Other Features We Like From Sur La Table 246598-1 Broiler Pans
Its deep pan and broiler lid means you can broil anything you normally would in a standard oven. It works wonders for making crispy bacon. This broiler pan is also big enough to cook meat and fish with or without vegetables for the whole family, and food for a solo meal or for two people.
We found its lid to be quite useful. When you take something out from the oven at such a high temperature, you don’t want to have to worry about spilling hot liquids all over yourself. Its lid is designed in a way to prevent this from happening.
Meanwhile, Sur La Table’s customer support services make the whole experience a pleasure. They’re polite, friendly, and ready to help with any problem.
There’s no need to scrub the surfaces of its pan and tray after soaking it in water. You can normally just wipe it clean with soapy water unless you have something stuck on its pan and tray. You can even use a dishwasher to bring back its stainless steel shine.
The Wilton 2-piece broiler pan measures 13.2 inches long, 8 inches wide and 2.2 inches deep. It weighs less than 1 lb. It’s made out of steel alloy, which is why it’s a bit bigger but lighter than the others in this list.
Even though it isn’t made from stainless steel, this product is still a non-stick broiler pan that’s quite easy to use. You can also put this in the dishwasher, but manually washing it with warm soapy water is highly recommended.
Keep in mind to wipe the broiler pan with a sponge or a cloth instead of a stainless steel scrubbing pad. This will prevent scratching its surface.
The only problem with steel is that it tends to rust, unlike stainless steel. So don’t forget to dry your Wilton broiler pan after washing it to prevent this.
What You Get When You Buy the Wilton Non-Stick Broiler Pan Set
The main baking tray of Wilton broiler pans is extra deep and ideal for lasagnas or cakes. The food will easily slide out.
Its broiler tray also has elevated ridges and many drain holes between the ridges. This means fat can quickly drain away, leaving you with healthy meat with lots of flavors. When you broil in a Wilton pan, the food stays moist with a crispy finish.
The Wilton Broiler pan comes with a 5-year limited warranty. It’s also among the most inexpensive ones in this list.
Other Features We Like From Wilton Non-Stick Broiler Pan Sets
The pan of the Wilton non-stick broiler set is designed with extra-wide handles. This makes it much safer and more convenient to use and carry around the kitchen. This also means you’re less likely to accidentally burn yourself. Remember, extra safety features are a huge positive when you’re dealing with such high temperatures.
Its 5-year limited warranty is an advantage here. Especially when you consider its reasonable price.
We also learned that this product is much easier to clean when you let the tray warm up a little bit before putting the food on it. You can also spray a thin layer of oil. But soaking it in water tends to make it easier for food residue and oils to wash away as you clean it.
The Wilton non-stick broiler pan set is also much lighter than the others in this list. But it still feels sturdy and durable. Plus, its size is ideal for preparing food for 1 to 3 people. For example, three chicken breasts can fit comfortably, with some extra space for vegetables
We also really like how the broiler sits deep into the pan. When fatty foods start to pop, it doesn’t cover your oven with grease, so a little less cleaning is required. Meanwhile, the depth of its pan means you can also make other dishes without having to buy an extra baking tray.
Frigidaire designed their 5304442087 broiler pan to fit in most standard-sized ovens. You can contact their customer support team to double-check the compatibility of this broiler pan with your oven. This product measures 15.8 inches long, 12.6 inches wide and 2.3 inches deep. It weighs 2.5 lbs. And is as sturdy as it looks.
This broiler pan is coated with porcelain, which helps to provide an even cook on meats. This coating means food just slides off without needing to use oil beforehand. It also absorbs heat to encourage further even cooking.
This product comes in cobalt blue. You do have to be careful with its porcelain coating. It can chip or scratch. In case it does, then it will only affect its appearance but not its functions.
You’re also recommended to soak it for a little while in warm soapy water as you clean it. Don’t try to scrub it clean as this can lead to small scratches.
What You Get When You Buy the Frigidaire 5304442087 Broiler Pan
This is a good quality product that can withstand the heat of broiling and won’t warp the bottom of its pan. You can fit a split chicken or even a rack of ribs. You won’t also have any problem crisping your vegetables with this broiler.
It’s a great all-around broiling pan that will tick the boxes for most people. But keep in mind that the Frigidaire 5304442087 broiler pan is among the most expensive products in this roundup.
Other Features We Like From Frigidaire 5304442087 Broiler Pans
This broiler is designed so that its pan sits on top of the baking tray like a lid. It has a small rim all the way around to secure its pan from slipping off. There’s also a lip around the inside, so juice that hasn’t made it down the draining slots won’t spill over the edge.
It has a rectangular shape with rounded corners. The coating of its surface is far better than other non-stick baking products. Even after multiple uses, the food still doesn’t stick. It’s really easy to clean, and even dried food residue can easily come off after being soaked in soapy water.
This is among the most popular broiler pans in the market this year. It’s slightly larger than the other broiler pans in this list, measuring at 18.2 inches long, 15.7 inches wide and 3 inches deep. But despite its bigger size, it weighs a mere 1 lbs.
The General Electric wB48X10056 broiler pan can be used in most average-sized ovens. It’s also dishwasher-safe.
The design of its drain slots is slightly different from the others in this roundup. These have a deep dip as well as a slightly raise area at its bottom. This is designed to drain away from the juice, oils, and fat. This can also help with air ventilation while you’re cooking food in this broiler, which is another method that helps cook the meat evenly.
What You Get When You Buy the General Electric WB48X10056 Broiler Pan
This broiler pan’s much larger size can allow you to prepare food for a few extra people. You can fit six average portions of fish, or even two or three steaks and a side dish of vegetables. This product is also quite sturdy despite its thin form and can last for a very long time because of its durable materials.
Be careful when handling the edges of its broiler pan. These are quite sharp and might cause minor cuts and other injuries.
Its broiler pan acts as a lid to prevent anything from slipping away. Its material is premium quality, as is its non-stick coating. It’s difficult to get food residue and oils stuck to this pan. It’s among the higher-priced products in this list, but we consider this broiler pan as a good investment for the kitchen.
Other Features We Like From General Electric W48X10056 Broiler Pans
The design of its slots made a difference on the final cook of the meat. We noticed that the overall color was brown, even the parts that weren’t as close to the heat. The food was cooked quickly without losing any flavor.
General Electric W48X10056 is a large broiler pan, making this product a handy tool when you have people over for dinner. You can broil food and still have space in your oven for other baking trays or dishes.
Its design is elegant and looks quite modern. We liked how it felt solid when we used it. You can tell it’s made from durable, high-quality materials.
This might look like a baking tray with a baking rack. But this is a good broiler primarily because of its design to withstand high temperatures of up to 450°F. This is another compact option at 10 inches long, 7 inches wide and 0.6 inches deep.
You can use the Nordic Ware 42210 broiler pan in your kitchen or even when you’re out on the road. Place it on outdoor stoves for your camping trips, RV ovens and in other regular indoor and outdoor ovens.
Its baking tray is made out of aluminum materials with a metallic gold non-stick coating. This product is straightforward to clean in warm soapy water. It’s made in the USA. Its broiler tray is aluminum and has been imported from China.
What You Get When You Buy the Nordic Ware 42210 Broiler Pan
The small size of this broiler pan offers a lot of advantages. You won’t need to take out a large baking tray to prepare dinner for 1 or even 2 to 3 people. Meanwhile, you can also fit meat or fish on it with a selection of vegetables, effectively preparing a whole meal in one go. If you want, then you can take away its broiling rack and directly use its pan for baking food.
Nordic products are PTFE and PFOA free. This provides peace of mind, knowing you’re using safe products. Any plastic that is used is BPA free. This means no harmful plastics will ever mix with your food.
You’ll get non-stick baking products from Nordic Ware that can easily be washed off in warm soapy water. Its rack is also non-stick, so no heavy cleaning there as well.
These broiler pans are excellent space savers, ideal if you have a small kitchen, or if you want to take them on days out or camping. And you can make almost anything in them from pies to broiled steaks and vegetables.
Other Features We Like From Nordic Ware 42210 Broiler Pans
We found it quite challenging to look for a much better broiler pan at this price than Nordic Ware 42210. This product is one of the most inexpensive broiler pans in this roundup. It also has a limited 5-year warranty, which is a sufficient statement for many buyers regarding how long it’ll last.
There’s also a 3-piece set that’s available as an option aside from their standard 2-piece product. This includes a deep-pan baking dish. Meanwhile, their 5-piece option comes with a deep-pan baking dish, muffin tray, and BPA-free plastic lid.
Its lid is so convenient if you want to cover the food for the next day. This is available in each of its options. Even their 5-piece set can provide you with excellent value for a reasonable price.
Nordic Ware broiler sets are brilliant value for money. They’re compact and can be used for a variety of purposes and places. They’re versatile so that you can do more than broil.
TeamFar’s broiler pan is simple and straightforward. It’s made from premium materials. Its tray measures 8 inches long, 10 inches wide and 1-inch deep. Now, this isn’t very deep, unlike the others in this list.
This means you won’t be able to use it for thick ingredients and recipes. Plus, this product only weighs 1.17 lbs. And feels quite strong and sturdy.
Its tray and broiler rack is made from high-quality stainless steel. There are no other materials or coating products. You can cook knowing that the food will be toxic-free. Its tray has rounded edges and a slight lip all the way around. You can take the broiler rack out and use it as a cooling rack for your baked goods.
What You Get When You Buy the TeamFar Ovenware Broiler Pan
The TeamFar Ovenware broiler pan is a 2-piece set. It’s quite handy, knowing that both parts are easy to clean. You can either wipe them off with warm water or place them in the dishwasher.
You can use the TeamFar ovenware for broiling, baking and roasting any type of meat, fish, and vegetables. You’ll be able to cook a whole chicken and even a small ham. Broiling the ham will evenly cook the meat and still keep its moisture and flavor while ensuring just the right crispiness for its external parts.
This product can also evenly cook vegetables with a brown finish, or charred if that’s what you want. Also, this broiler pan comes with a reasonable price tag, which is more inexpensive than some of the products in this list.
Other Features We Like From TeamFar Ovenware Broiler Pans
One of the main features we like in TeamFar Ovenware broilers is its rust-free design. After all, it’s quite disheartening to buy something new and to see rust appear. This also means you can enjoy a shiny broiler pan for a long time because its rust-free form is coupled with easy maintenance and cleanup features.
You can tell it’s a high-quality product as soon as you hold and use it. Plus, TeamFar has a wonderful customer support crew. If for any reason there’s a problem, then they’ll be happy to help you out or give you a refund.
So it might be in your best interest to get this in case you have an old aluminum broiler pan. The food you prepare with this broiler can be much healthier because oils and fat easily drain away. Meanwhile, you’ll have an easy time cleaning and using this broiler for a long time as it doesn’t stain or warp under high temperatures.
What’s the Best Broiler Pan in This 2019 Roundup?
Lots of buyers recommend the Whirlpool 4396923 broiler pan. This is if you’re looking for a broiler that can help you regularly prepare food for a big family or a larger group of people. And you can also opt for the Granite Ware Bake Broil pan in case you want a more inexpensive option.
But the General Electric wB48X10056 broiler pan can also be a good lightweight alternative for a broiler that can prepare larger food servings although we don’t particularly like its sharp edges, which can cause minor cuts and other accidental injuries.
Meanwhile, if you’re searching for more compact broilers, then many buyers recommend the Nordic Ware 42210 broiler pan. This is a space-saving product with versatile functions for indoor and outdoor cooking. It also comes with lots of options at really affordable prices, such as its 2-piece, 3 and 5-piece models.
Another compact broiler that’s ideal for small servings for indoor and outdoor cooking is the TeamFar Ovenware broiler. We especially like its rust-proof design.
So again, your choice primarily depends on your exact needs, purposes, budget, and requirements. Carefully weigh these alternatives and compare its form and function against each other. You’re now able to conveniently do this because of all the details that we supplied in this roundup of the ten best broiler pans in the market this 2019. Our objective is to provide you with helpful information so you can make a more informed buying decision.
Why Do You Need a Broiler Pan?
The main reason you need a broiler pan is that other pans are unable to withstand the heat needed to broil meat. Most broiled foods need to be cooked at around 500–550°F although low broil functions work at around 450°F.
The idea is fast cooking under a close heat as you rotate the meat to give an all-over browned cook. Broiling is a method of cooking that’s similar to grilling and frying, i.e., It’s like frying because you’re able to cook meat very quickly, but it’s also similar to grilling because there isn’t the associated fat as with frying.
Overall, you get the flavor of frying with the health benefits of grilling. Remember, the heat comes from the bottom when you grill food, rising through the food. Think of a barbeque rather than an oven grill that’ll cook your toast.
Meanwhile, heat comes from above the meat when broiling. Now broilers are incredibly versatile. Think about the difference of a roast meal in a large Pyrex glass dish.
The oils, fat, and juices from the meat will run through the vegetables. This means you can broil meat and vegetables in one broiling pan. The fat is drained away, keeping the food healthy while your vegetables remain tasty and crisp.
How to Choose the Right Broiler Pan?
No matter how hard you try, broiler pans (and all baking trays) wear out after use. It’s one of those annoying facts of life. Most broiler pans are durable but are unlikely to last as long as the oven does. Heat, food particles getting stuck, and repeated cleaning can gradually damage your broiler pan. There will come a time to get a new one.
But who knew there were so many broiler pan varieties? There are stainless steel, carbon steel, non-stick, with holes, with raised grooves, etc.
When looking for a broiling pan, check that it ticks all of the boxes you require. If you have bought a new oven, it may not necessarily come with baking trays or broiling pans. In this case, you will need one that will fit your oven. There is no point in buying one for its dishwasher friendliness if you don’t have a dishwasher. Are you likely to use a deep baking tray for other meals, or is it just going to take extra space in your kitchen? Whether you choose stainless steel, steel, or porcelain depends on what you prefer. And finally, paying a higher price or choosing a more popular brand doesn’t mean you’re going to get a better broiler pan.
So you’ll need to check its size. This is to make sure that it’s compatible with your oven. Some come in compact sizes, so you’ll need an extra tray for it to sit on.
Next, remember that this isn’t often just a case of choosing the cheapest. Don’t forget that you’re now able to select a broiler pan with features that tick all of your requirements, including your budget. Also, keep in mind that broiler pans now usually come with extras.