We may earn commission from the links in this post
Here we talk about the ten best cake pop makers of the year. Our roundup was compiled from the findings of our testers as they tried each one out. We considered the appearance, functions, and how easy each product in our list was to use.
Our test group consists of beginners, intermediate, and expert bakers who know their way around a cake pop maker. We also considered the opinions and reviews of buyers from around the world. We looked closer at their posts as they shared their experience in using this product across the online communities and social media pages that we frequent.
Cake Pop Makers Review Center 2019
|Image||Cake Pop Maker||Rating|
|#1 - VonShef 12 Cake Pop Maker||82%|
|#2 - Tosnail Silicone Cake Pop Maker||80%|
|#3 - Babycakes Mini Cake Pop Maker||80%|
|#4 - Cucina Pro Multi Baker Deluxe||80%|
|#5 - Brentwood Cake Pop Maker||78%|
|#6 - Patisse Nonstick Cake Pop Maker||76%|
|#7 - Cakes Of Eden Cake Pop Maker Kit||76%|
|#8 - Babycakes Flip Over Cake Pop Maker||77%|
|#9 - Rbenxia Silicone Cake Pop Maker||72%|
|#10 - Holstein Housewares Cake Pop Maker||68%|
Plus, these cake pop makers made it on to our list because of the results from our extensive tests. This is how we formed our roundup of the ten best cake pop makers of 2019. And here are our detailed findings:
#1 – VonShef 12 Cake Pop Maker
The VonShef cake pop maker can make 12 cakes in around 4 minutes. Its design is sleek and modern in a nice metallic red. Its baking plates are non-stick, although we aren’t sure about the material.
You can wipe the inside and outside of the cake pop maker with a damp cloth, and it’ll look as good as new. It’s a convenient size with a flat back. You can turn it vertically to fit in a cupboard. It weighs 4.6 lbs.
You’ll know when the machine is ready through its indicator lights. Along with the cake pop maker, you’ll receive a 12-hole cake stand and 50 sticks. It’s a good starter set or gift for a keen baker.
What We Like About It:
The first thing we noticed about this product is its design. Some tend to look a little bit more playful than we wanted. But the VonShef is something that looks smart on our tables and countertops. We even found that after cleaning, it kept its shiny design.
It took us a little practice to get the cake pops right. We noticed that the batter needed to be thicker than normal. Some people received a recipe with it. If you follow the recipe, you’ll get perfect cake balls.
Once we got the hang of it, it was easy to make identical cakes that were fluffy and tasty. One of the members in our test group manages to make 60 in only half an hour. This is awesome if you need to prepare for a party. After all, cooking 60 in the oven would have taken at least double the time without the same result.
The general opinion is that this cake pop maker heats up very quickly, which also speeds things up.
#2 – Tosnail Silicone Cake Pop Maker
This option is the best for anyone who needs to make cake pops in huge batches. Each mold can make 16 cake pops. In total, you can make 32 cakes in one go.
Its molds are made of premium quality food-grade silicone. They’re BPA, PVC, and Phthalate-free. There’s no risk of harmful toxins coming in contact. You’re your food. You can use the molds in the oven up to 450 °F.
These molds are safe for the dishwasher. For the best results, you should rinse it under running water first. You can also put them in the freezer. So recipes could be cake pops, brownie bites, pizza bites, and even frozen treats like ice pops or frozen yogurt balls.
Its molds are 7.25 x 7.25 inches. They’re flexible and easy to store in different places. The diameter of the balls is 1.5 inches, so they are the average size. Plus, there are holes in the top to check if the cakes are cooked.
What We Like About It:
Our favorite thing was most definitely the value for money. This set is only just in the double figures, and you can cook 32 pop cakes in one go. You might be able to cook a cake pop for each kid in class in just 12 to 15 minutes.
Pro chefs in our test group made this set look incredibly quick and easy to use. We set the challenge to see how many cake pops could be made in an hour. One chef made 128. And that included time for filling the molds.
Novices needed to practice a little more. But once they had the right batter consistency, there were no problems for them to make 64 cake pops in 40 minutes on average.
There are no added extras like sticks or plastic wraps. But we weren’t fussed about that. This pack of 2 is a brilliant value that allows you to make tons of perfectly shaped cake pops ready for decorating.
#3 – Babycakes Mini Cake Pop Maker
Here we have a lovely purple cake pop maker. It is lightweight at just 1.7 lbs and can make nine pop cakes at a time. You can make loads of different recipes like red velvet, lemon cakes, chocolate, and maraschino cherry, among many others.
The baking plates are non-stick. Once you have sprayed the tray with oil, you can fill the mold with your favorite batter and close the lid. The lid has a latch to keep it safely closed. The non-skid rubber feet will stop the cake pop maker from moving as you use it.
After the cakes are baked, all you have to do is wipe the baking plates with a damp cloth. Also, there is a handy cord wrap to keep the machine tidy when it’s stored.
You aren’t limited to just cakes. This cake pop will make delicious bacon and cheddar bites, pizza bites, hush puppies, Swedish meatballs, and lots more. Cake pops are cooked evenly in a few minutes.
What We Like About It:
This is brilliant for quickly making perfectly round cake pops. We were able to make 50 pop cakes in just under an hour. One of our novice testers made 100 in two and a half hours. This is ideal for those who like to bake in bulk.
Its non-stick baking trays impressed the professionals in our test group. These were non-stick, so the cakes just slide out with no issues. At one point, a tester overfilled the baking tray, and we had a bit of spillage. But it was easy just to wipe away the batter, even when cooked.
We also felt that this was a good cake pop maker for beginners. It was so easy to get the right shape compared with other methods. It comes with a few recipe ideas, and the instruction manual also provides useful hints to help you.
There’s no risk of burning the food because the light indicator tells you when it is ready. It’s so straightforward that kids can take part (with supervision). It’s great value for money, especially when you think of how much you can spend on cake pops.
#4 – Cucina Pro Multi Baker Deluxe
Cucina Pro has produced a high quality set with three interchangeable plates. There is a grilling skillet for pizzas and sandwiches. There is a dessert maker and of course the cake pop maker. This has the capacity for 18 cakes with a diameter of 1.5 inches.
The cake pop maker can also make meatballs, takoyaki (a Japanese snack), and any other recipe you can think of that comes in small round balls.
It has a temperature range from 300 to 450F. This is a huge advantage over other cake pop makers as you have more control. Cake pops will take just a few minutes. Meat recipes like meatballs will be ready between 8 and 12 minutes. The cooking time will also depend on the desired color.
There’s very little information on the materials used, which is a shame. It’s advertised as easy to clean, so we can assume it is non-stick. There’s no lid with this set, so be prepared to flip your recipes.
What We Like About It:
We didn’t realize that the cord was detachable. This made the cake pop maker easier to store and transport. We also didn’t know that the plates could be put in the dishwasher. Our professional testers advised against this because it could affect the non-stick material.
Everybody loved the versatility of the plates and how easy it was to switch them. We were able to make a good range of delicious snacks. One online review managed to make egg McMuffins!
Because there wasn’t a lid, we found it easier to make some foods. Stuffed pancake balls were great because you could start the cooking process and then add chocolate spread. It kept the filling more intact.
We felt that this was certainly a set that you would want to get out at a party. You will have fun cooking together. There are multiple cooking options, and with 18 holes, you can make lots of food quickly.
#5 – Brentwood Cake Pop Maker
Purple seems to be a popular color for cake pop makers. Brentwood has a well-priced maker with 12 holes. The plates are non-stick. The cakes will slide out, and cleaning only requires a wipe with a cloth.
Included in the box is a recipe booklet. You can make vanilla and lemon cake pops, pancake bites, and cinnamon sugar donuts.
There are two indicator lights to show that the power is on and preheated. The machine comes with an automatic shut off when it senses overheating. There are vertical feet so that you can save storage space. Another nice safety feature is the cool touch handles to prevent burns when you open and close the lid.
It’s a very powerful machine with 750 watts. The cakes are made in 4 minutes. It’s a nice looking machine that will add a bit of color to your kitchen.
What We Like About It:
We had a lot of fun making cake pops. We also felt that it was one of the safest makers, so we were more confident letting children have a go at baking. We learned from an Amazon reviewer that it’s even easier if you use a squeezy bottle or piping bag.
The recipe that came with the maker is fine, and the results were good. It was great for those who didn’t have any idea where to start. Bakers and professionals were happier with their recipes.
The cakes were just the right golden brown color. They held their shape very well, even when frosting. Everybody thought it was a great kitchen tool for saving time.
We decided this is one of the best cake-pop makers for value for money. The materials are of good quality; it’s easy to clean and is safe. It’s good for beginners and professionals.
#6 – Patisse Nonstick Cake Pop Maker
This is relatively new and has only come on sale on Amazon this year. Rather than a silicone mold, it is made of steel. It’s heavy but sturdier, so it’s easier putting it in the oven with batter in it.
It’s a 0.40-0.60mm high-quality steel gauge with a non-stick coating. The coating is Whitford Skandia 8-10 micron coating. It’s best to hand wash this mold to prevent damaging the non-stick coating.
You will get 18 cake pops in a batch. We aren’t sure why you receive a pack of 16 sticks. Each mold has a diameter of 1.75 inches. This is slightly wider than many molds.
There are two handy clips on the ends of the tray. You can put these on to keep the top and bottom trays in place. There are also holes in the top for you to do the stick test for cooking time.
It’s a little expensive, considering you don’t receive any other extras (apart from the sticks). It is a top-quality cake pop mold that will last for a long time if you take care of it.
What We Like About It:
This was the first cake pop mold we tested with a non-stick coating. Because of this, we were a bit nervous about scratching it, so we used a tiny bit of spray beforehand. This did the trick, and cleaning it was easy. We just rinsed it with a soft cloth and warm soapy water.
We liked using a metal mold compared with the plastic. We found that the cooking time was a little less ad the cakes were nice and moist. The plastic clips were really practical because, without them, we don’t think they would have stayed in line.
The professionals also felt that the results were superior. The taste was moist, and the texture was fluffy. The outer layer of the cake was firm, so it was also easy to decorate them without crumbs falling off.
#7 – Cakes Of Eden Cake Pop Maker Kit
This is the perfect set for someone who wants to make cake pops but doesn’t want to buy a machine. Not only that, but it also comes with every needed to make 100 cake pops.
To make cake pops, you just fill the silicone mold, snap together the second mold on top and place it in the oven. Cooking time is between 12 and 20 minutes. However, you can make 20 cakes in one batch. The silicone id food-grade and FDA approved.
With this set, you get a microwavable melting pot, which is also FDA approved food-grade silicone. This can be put in the dishwasher. You get 20 short white lollipop sticks and 100 long pink sticks.
You even get a 3-tier cake stand that holds up to 40 cake pops. It’s durable and BPA free plastic. There’s a decorating pen and 100 plastic bags and ties to wrap the cake pops.
Cakes Of Eden stands behind its products. There is a 90-day trial period. If you aren’t happy, the company will but the setback and donate it to a children’s charity.
What We Like About It:
It was so well packaged in a nice box with paper. You can tell that Cakes Of Eden care about its products. We also very much appreciated the quality of the products and the materials it uses. The fact that it’s BPA free and FDA approved means you know you aren’t ingesting harmful chemicals.
It’s a lovely set if you want to start making cake pops or if you want to give it to someone as a gift.
We felt that using a silicone mold instead of a machine is more suited to those who have experience. Using an oven takes a little more practice. Even though it took longer than a machine, it does have a larger capacity.
The taste of the cakes was perfect. They were light and fluffy, with just the right amount of color. We tried it with store-bought mixture and homemade mixture with excellent results.
Altogether, we thought this was a fantastic set at a great price. It’s made with quality and care and does a perfect job of making cake pops.
#8 – Babycakes Flip Over Cake Pop Maker
We like the Babycakes brand so much we thought this option was also worthy of the list. The design is very different from a base and a cake pop maker that can be flipped during the cooking. It also has 12 holes so that you can make more.
The idea behind rotating the cakes is so that the result is a rounder, more even finish. It’s not just for cake pops. You’ll find a recipe book in the box to give you ideas for sweet and savory snacks.
It’s slightly heavier than the Babycakes standing model. It weighs 5.45lbs, but the design is still easy to store. The plates are non-stick, so you only need to wipe it clean with a cloth.
It has non-skid rubber feet for safety. On the lid, there’s a light for power and ready. It’s made in China but has a U.S. ETL listing, so you know it has been tested for its safety.
Along with the cake pop maker, you’ll receive a battered bottle, a fork tool, 50 sticks, and two plastic cooling racks. It has everything you need to start cooking straight away.
What We Like About It:
We appreciated the extras that came with the cake pop maker. It made the whole process easier. Some of our testers weren’t big bakers and didn’t own a cooling rack. We were slightly confused when some of us received a miniature crockpot that can be used as a chocolate dipper. Those who received it were over the moon.
Our chefs and non-professionals noticed the difference in even color and texture with the flip over cake pop maker. We don’t think it’s possible to make a rounder ball. This improved the appearance once we had decorated them too.
The customer service was exceptional. We called to ask several questions about the product and how to use it. They were very friendly and helpful. It’s a little pricey, but we thought it was worth it for the better results and more cakes made.
#9 – Rbenxia Silicone Cake Pop Maker
This cake pop mold made it onto the top 10 list as the best budget buy. It’s a fraction of the cost of others we’ve seen. That being said, you can still make up to 20 cake pops in a batch.
The mold is 22.5cm long and 18cm wide. The cake pops will have a 4cm diameter. You can also use it to make muffins or mini quiches. The silicone is made from food-grade silicone.
It’s flexible and non-stick. You can hand wash it or put it in the dishwasher. Because it can also go in the freezer, you can make yummy frozen treats too. It is oven safe up to temperatures of 450F.
The pack includes two pink plastic molds and 25 7cm sticks. There are holes in the top lid. These are designed for you to insert a stick to check to see if they are cooked. Once the two molds click together, they are very well sealed.
What We Like About It:
We loved the simplicity. There are no frills, but you get exactly what you need to make a large batch of cake pops.
Some of our testers used a shop-bought cake mix. This was enough for them to make around 80 balls in 4 batches. Regardless of the type of batter, the cakes took around 15 minutes to bake, and we found that 350F was the ideal temperature.
To get the best shape, we noticed that it was best to fill the molds just under the brim. More would make a mess, less wouldn’t fill the frame when the batter rose.
Amazon reviewers advised us to spay the molds first. We tried this and found that the balls just popped out, and the trays rinsed off easily.
Again, if you have a little bit of experience with cake pops, this silicone set from Rbenxia is excellent value.
#10 – Holstein Housewares Cake Pop Maker
The bright red cake pop maker can make 14 cakes at once in minutes. It’s also available in teal and magenta. The diameter of the cake pops is 1.5 inches.
It’s not just for cake recipes. You can make sweet or savory snacks. It comes with a recipe book to give you plenty of ideas.
The upper housing is made from modern stainless steel. The baking trays are non-stick to prevent your treats from breaking up as you try to remove them. It also makes cleaning up easier with just the swipe of a cloth.
The indicator light lets you know when the cake pop maker has reached the correct temperature. You will have to keep an eye on the baking time. The lid closes with a safety lock so as not to open it while it is cooking.
When horizontal, the Holstein cake pop maker sits on anti-slip feet and an anti-slip base. It can be turned onto its side for easy storage and doesn’t take up too much space.
What We Like About It:
We all loved the light, moist cakes that it made. Some used store-bought cake mixture while others used their batter. Both options turned out delicious. One Amazon review made brownie bites, which inspired us to try! They went down a treat with the kids.
The batter starts cooking quickly and rising. We found that you had to fill up the tray quite quickly to prevent the batter from overflowing. The colored manual also gave us some good advice.
It was quite nerve-wracking waiting for the correct time without opening the lid. Nobody burnt their cakes, but we found that our results got better after a few batches. This way, we had more control over the color we got.
This saves you a lot of time, especially if you are preparing for a party or bake sale. The traditional method was time-consuming, and it took a long time to clean up. From taking it out of the cupboard to cleaning it, we made 28 cake pops in 10 minutes.
It’s pricier than others, but the taste is worth it.
So, here you have our list of cake pop makers. Some are machines, and some are molds. We have included something to suit everyone. We paid close attention to what online reviewers were saying and other social media sites. But the final opinions came down to the testers, both professional and novice bakers. Thanks to them, we were able to provide you with the top 10 cake pop makers for 2019.
What is a Cake Pop Maker?
A cake pop maker is designed to help you quickly and conveniently produce bite-sized treats and snacks. But you aren’t limited to just cakes in the size and shape of a small cupcake. Rather, you can use this product for other recipes, such as mini pizza servings, tiny bite-sized sandwiches and so on —Your creativity and imagination will enable you to take advantage of these cake pop makers fully.
How Do Cake Pop Makers Work?
A cake pop maker is often equipped with non-stick baking plates. These are built into the product and are integrated with small molds where you put your batter. The sizes and shapes of these molds depend on the form factor design of your cake pop maker.
All you need to do is to put your batter in these molds. Just be careful not to put too much batter in each mold as it will overflow and spill all over the baking plate, which can give you irregularly shaped pops.
Afterward, close its lid and turn it on. Most cake pop makers are equipped with temperature and timer controls. They’re also integrated with indicator lights and an alert that notifies you when it’s finished baking. So put on a pair of oven mittens, get a fork, open the lid of your cake pop maker and take out each of your cake pops to cool it down. And that’s how quick and simple it is to produce tasty snacks and treats with this product.
But because of the wide variety of cake pop makers in the market today, you need to pay close attention to a number of factors especially. You must carefully consider these things. This’ll significantly improve your chances of picking the most suitable product from our list of the ten best cake pop makers this 2019. So here you go:
Factors to Consider When Buying a Cake Pop Maker
- Form Factor Design — Aside from the size and shape of your cake pop maker, its look and feel should be among your top considerations when searching for the top 10 cake pop makers in the market today. That’s because you wouldn’t want a product that clashes with the style and theme of your kitchen, right? As for its size and shape, be sure to choose one that’s equipped with a space-saving form factor design. This is so you can place and store it conveniently in and around your kitchen each time you want to use it, and also after every use;
- Serving Capacity & Mold Shape — Do you intend to regularly use your cake pop maker to serve to say 2 to 3 adults and 2 to 4 kids? Or do you plan to use it for much bigger get-togethers like dinner parties with your friends and colleagues? The point is, you need to consider these things before you move on to our list of the best cake-pop makers today. That’s because this can allow you to identify the cake pop maker with the most suitable capacity and mold shape for your exact objectives;
- Food-Grade Materials you wouldn’t want to endanger the health of your loved ones by serving them treats and snacks that came in contact with harmful chemicals and other toxic elements, right? So choose a cake pop maker that’s made out of high-quality food-grade materials and components;
- Features — Won’t it be convenient to get a cake pop maker with indicator lights to inform you about its current status? How about an audible alert that can notify you as soon as it’s done baking your batch of treats? Of course, full control over temperature and timer settings is bound to provide you with much convenience, right? More so, a quick and simple way to take out your pops once they’re finished baking is a beneficial feature in a cake pop maker. Also, don’t forget to check just how simple it is to clean and store in and around your kitchen. Many products in our list are integrated with dishwasher-safe features. So check the stuff that’s equipped into each of the products in our roundup of the ten best cake pop makers for your kitchen this 2019. By doing this, you’ll be able to spot the right one for your particular needs;
- Sturdiness & Durability — Some products tend to break down, especially after prolonged heavy use easily. So keep in mind to choose a cake pop maker that can last for a long time and can accommodate the regularity and capacity that you require. Usually, cake pop makers intended for the exact capacity that you need are manufactured and tested to withstand your particular use case scenario without issues;
- Warranty & Guarantees — Remember, the warranty and guarantees that come bundled with a product are often indicative of the results of its manufacturer’s rigorous torture tests. Simply put, when a product comes with a 3-year warranty and a guarantee to accommodate five or more persons, then this often means its manufacturer ran a series of tests and found out that their product can last for up to 3 years even with prolonged heavy use. So keep this in mind as you’ll be able to save a lot of time, energy and money when you select the right product for your exact situation; and
- Price & Freebies — Of course, price plays a major role in the entire buying process. This applies to any product that you want. But just keep in mind, the value of a product is often associated with the benefits and advantages that you can gain from using it. So always remember to only pay for the exact value that you want. Plus, consider the freebies and other value-added promos that come with the ten best cake pop makers in our roundup. This way, you’ll get more bang for your buck.
Now consider these vital factors as you go through our list of the top 10 cake pop makers for your kitchen this 2019.
Do You Need a Cake Pop Maker?
The quickest and simplest answer, in our opinion, is yes. But that’s if you often want bite-sized treats and snacks to satisfy your sweet tooth. That’s because, with a cake pop maker that’s most suitable for individuals and a small group of 2 to 3 persons, you won’t need to tediously bake large cakes and keep them in the fridge so that you can enjoy a nice serving of sweet treats now and then.
You can also gain a lot of benefits and advantages from any of the ten best cake pop makers in our roundup for 2019 if you have a family that regularly wants tasty snacks and sweet pastries. By getting the right cake pop maker, you’ll be able to prepare and serve them with bite-sized treats quickly.
And some of the products in our list of the ten best cake pop makers this 2019 can also be used for commercial kitchens. But this also means even if you just intend to serve your guests at private dinner parties, meetings, and get-together, then these cake pop makers are suitable options for you to do this conveniently. So just keep in mind to carefully consider the most important factors that we listed at the beginning, and you’ll be able to pinpoint the exact cake pop maker from our roundup.
User Review( votes)