America’s Favorite Sandwich Cookie in a Sinful Pie Form
What could be better than an Oreo cookie and a nice cold glass of milk? If you haven’t tried the Jell-O Oreo No Bake Dessert, you might be inclined to say nothing. With one taste of this luscious, creamy dessert the plain old cookie will never seem the same again.
Jell-O No Bake recipes take just 15 minutes to make and only require two ingredients beyond the contents of the box. To make this recipe, add 4 tablespoons of butter to the Oreo crust mix and press it firmly into a pie plate covering the bottom and sides evenly.
Recommended Reading: Get started with baking by reading our Ultimate Guide to the Best Baking Equipment for Beginners!
Next, combine the contents of the filling packet with 1-1/3 cups of cold milk in a large bowl. Use an electric mixer to blend the ingredients for 30 seconds on low first, then for a full 3 minutes on medium. Once the filling is mixed, add half the contents of the Oreo cookie pieces, and gently fold into the filling mix. Spoon the mixture into the crust and refrigerate for one hour.
When ready to serve, top the pie with the remaining Oreo cookie pieces. For ease of serving, Jell-O suggests dipping the pie plate to the rim in warm water before cutting.
The dessert is an Oreo filling lovers dream. It’s light, airy, and tastes just like the filling of an Oreo cookie. The cookie pieces and crust balance out the sweetness of the filling. When making this dessert, be sure several other people will be around to eat it. Otherwise, it will call you from the refrigerator, and it can quite possibly be finished off in a 24-hour period. It is that good.
A serving size is considered 1/6 of the pie which is a very generous serving. The dessert’s calories as prepared with the added milk and butter is 370, with 150 calories from fat. Additional nutritional values are based on a preparation using 2% reduced fat milk.
Total Fat – 8 g
Saturated Fat – 5 g
Trans Fat – 2 g
Cholesterol – 5 mg
Sodium – 540 mg
Total Carbohydrates – 51 g
Dietary Fiber – 2g
Sugars – 28 g
Protein – 4 g
Vitamin A – 8%
Vitamin C – 0%
Calcium – 10 %
Iron – 10%
Value & Satisfaction
The Jell-O No Bake Oreo Dessert is very reasonably priced under $3.00 per box or less if it is on sale.
This dessert deserves a 5-star rating its overall taste, value, and ease of preparation. It will cure a sweet tooth, an Oreo craving, and be a huge hit among the dessert crowd. It’s dangerously delicious so it should probably be reserved for special occasions.
The package directions include several variations for serving the dessert including cupcakes, squares, freezes, dirt bowls, and cookie balls. These serving suggestions don’t require much additional preparation time or work. Additionally, adding mint extract or other flavorings will give the dessert a homemade touch.
It’s easy to be really creative with the type of dish used- so think beyond a traditional pie plate.
The recipe can be easily doubled for larger families and frozen for make-ahead meal planning.
While you’re here, be sure to check out our kitchen product reviews!
Average rating / 5. Vote count: